
(for a 2020 update, see below)
September 23, 2011—When we hear the
prediction of a comet, many of us set an alarm to wake up at oh-dark-thirty, go
outside with a telescope, and peer at blurry blobs on the horizon. I did that
several times, for Halley’s, Ikeya-Zhang, and Hale-Bopp. The best I could
recognize with binoculars was a tiny, glowing cotton ball. But life went on as
usual each time, because our culture no longer associates doom with a chunk of
icy dust passing through our solar system.
For thousands of years, a comet was believed to presage
death, disease, famine, and war. It was considered by many cultures to be a
sign of divine favor or judgment. You can't blame them for their superstition about a natural event,
because plague and war actually did follow. (William and Anne Marbury
Hutchinson of Alford, Lincolnshire lost two daughters to plague in
1630.)
A noon-time comet was reported in England,
Germany, and Italy on May 29
and 30, 1630. It was said to resemble a second sun and to shine so
brightly that there was a double shadow.
The comet of 1630 was described by Abbot Assi of Milan as a blazing star,
with a "savage face," and of a “horifica
specie,” (“horrific kind”). He said that it preceded “de peste quae fuit anno
1630” (“the pestilence which was the year 1630”).
Sure enough, in England
and much of Europe, plague and famine followed
the comet sighting.
Mary Barrett, age 19, and William Dyer, 21, who didn’t marry
until 1633, lived in London
at the time of the comet, and they almost certainly witnessed it. In the
bubonic plague which struck Europe and England
that year, they came through unscathed, though surely they lost friends and
relatives when a third of London's citizens died. Perhaps they fled the city for
some months, like other people who had the financial means to do so.
In New England, about 300
of the 1000 settlers in Massachusetts Bay Colony died of fever, scurvy, and
accident, and their winter of 1630-31 was called The Starving Time. Considering
that they’d emigrated to America
to found a New Jerusalem, the colonists must have wondered how they had
displeased God, to be visited so harshly.
Stars and comets also were believed to mark special dates
connected with world events, like births or deaths of kings. Some think it was
Halley’s Comet that shown in the sky over Bethlehem in 12 BC.
![]() |
The 1066 Halley's comet, depicted in Bayeux Tapestry. The English believed it prophesied doom. |
Halley’s Comet, said to
be four times the size of Jupiter, showed itself in 1066, a year of cataclysm
in England,
as Edward the Confessor died and Harold was anointed king in violation of his
oath of fealty to William “The Conqueror,” Duke of Normandy. William won the
crown for himself later that year.
The first comet to appear in the heavens of New England, of which there is any account, blazed forth from Orion from the ninth to the twenty-second of December, 1652. It was large, and people shuddered when they looked at its beautiful tail of fire.The people connected their appearance with some famine, plague or disaster, either as its direct cause or precursor; and the learned men of the times taught the people to fear their approach. When it is considered that some persons are still disturbed at their coming in this very end of the nineteenth century, it is readily understood why the people of the days when superstition was fostered trembled at their appearance. They seemed to be the perfection of instruments to accomplish the burning of the world.The clergy of New England sought to make the most of this belief and fear, either hypocritically, to simply increase the membership of their churches, or because they shared the common belief and honesty endeavored to have souls prepared for the great change that might come immediately, and without further warning. At these periods many were brought into the fold, and the ordinances and services of the church were more carefully observed. –The Essex [Massachusetts] Antiquarian magazine, 1898, edited by Sydney Perley
More great anecdotes about mid-17th century
England and New England, supported by research,
can be found in the nonfiction book
The DYERS of London, Boston, & Newport,
by Christy K Robinson.
It's the third in a series about Mary Dyer, Anne
Hutchinson, Sir Henry Vane, Roger Williams,
and John Winthrop.
Other momentous events, not necessarily negative, were associated with comets. When the noon-day comet appeared in May 1630, it was believed to mark the
birth of Charles II, the son of the English King Charles I and his queen
Henrietta Maria.
After the English Civil War of the 1640s, the execution of Charles I, and Oliver Cromwell's Protectorate, Charles II had been restored to the monarchy in London two days before Mary Dyer was hanged in Boston for civil disobedience to the church-state authority.
The April 1661 coronation publicity lauded him as a sort of messiah unifying the war-torn kingdom, and mentioned the 1630 birth comet as proof of him being God's choice for anointed king.
![]() |
Charles II coronation procession, April 21, 1661. It looks very messianic with the white gate and clouds. |
The poet Waller referred to the comet in his coronation
poem, “On St. James’s Park,” in the lines,
His thoughts rise
higher, when he does reflect
On what the world may
from that star expect,
Which at his birth
appeared, to let us see
Day, for his sake,
could with the night agree!
A Prince on whom such
diff’rent lights did smile,
Born the divided world
to reconcile!
The next comet to appear was in 1661, the Ikeya-Zhang. You can read an account from 1799 that described the connection between comets and practically every other disaster known to man, HERE.
The PAN-STARRS comet
![]() |
Source: space.com |
UPDATE March 13, 2013—Until relatively recently in world
history, people of all cultures connected the appearance of comets with great
events like the birth of a king, the onset of a new era, or a prophecy for good
or ill.
![]() |
Jorge Borgoglio, Pope Francis I as of March 13, 2013 |
And now, at the same time as the election of new Pope Francis I,
Jorge Bergoglio of Argentina,
spiritual ruler of more than a billion Catholics, we are treated to the comet
PAN-STARRS. Ten generations ago, this coincidence would have rocked
the world of our ancestors!
What we now consider a naturally-occurring event was then considered the hand
of God declaring the execution of his will.
UPDATE July 2020—As I waited for darkness 40 miles outside Phoenix's city lights in the desert near Highway US 60, I scanned the northwestern sky under the bucket of the Big Dipper with my binoculars, and remembered posting this Comet of Doom article nine years ago. I'm not a superstitious person at all, but I couldn't help smiling in the quiet darkness as I remembered the research I'd done and the graphic art of 500 years ago, connecting comets with plague and famine, war and economic devastation.
I began thinking of all the 2020 Apocalypse Bingo card squares, tragedies and freaky nature we could not have predicted:
Closer to home, there were five evil hornworms that attacked my beloved pasilla chili pepper plant, devouring all but one leaf before I dispatched them to hornworm perdition.
Out in the Sonoran Desert, it was 100 degrees with no humidity, no breeze, and the occasional buzz of insects. Even the coyotes and roadrunners were hunkered down. I watched the stars of the Milky Way begin to shine, and observed either a satellite or the ISS fly over from south to north. I did find a very faint Comet Neowise glow, but my cameras didn't have time exposure features, so my photos turned out pure black.
http://amzn.to/18zlbtt (Amazon author page)
The NEOWISE comet
UPDATE July 2020—As I waited for darkness 40 miles outside Phoenix's city lights in the desert near Highway US 60, I scanned the northwestern sky under the bucket of the Big Dipper with my binoculars, and remembered posting this Comet of Doom article nine years ago. I'm not a superstitious person at all, but I couldn't help smiling in the quiet darkness as I remembered the research I'd done and the graphic art of 500 years ago, connecting comets with plague and famine, war and economic devastation.
I began thinking of all the 2020 Apocalypse Bingo card squares, tragedies and freaky nature we could not have predicted:
- a worldwide pandemic, millions of jobs lost, economic depression, country lockdowns and quarantines, hundreds of thousands of people dead in the first wave of COVID-19, food-gasoline-hygiene supply shortages,
- widespread civil unrest in the US and other countries,
- locust swarms in east Africa,
- massive dust clouds from the Sahara drifting over the United States,
- Australian bushfires,
- a British 50-mile-wide cloud of flying ants, and yes,
- murder hornets. We had to have murder hornets.
Closer to home, there were five evil hornworms that attacked my beloved pasilla chili pepper plant, devouring all but one leaf before I dispatched them to hornworm perdition.
Out in the Sonoran Desert, it was 100 degrees with no humidity, no breeze, and the occasional buzz of insects. Even the coyotes and roadrunners were hunkered down. I watched the stars of the Milky Way begin to shine, and observed either a satellite or the ISS fly over from south to north. I did find a very faint Comet Neowise glow, but my cameras didn't have time exposure features, so my photos turned out pure black.
![]() |
With what we've seen and experienced in 2020, could pterodactyls, Godzilla, and sea serpents be far off? Check out Calamityware designs: I guess things could be worse! (I receive no compensation for posting the link to this product. I just love the humor of the designer.) |
*****
Christy K Robinson is author of the books:
·
We
Shall Be Changed (2010)
· Mary Dyer Illuminated (2013)
· Mary Dyer: For Such a Time as This (2014)
· The Dyers of London, Boston, & Newport (2014)
· Effigy Hunter (2015)
· Anne Marbury Hutchinson: American Founding Mother (2018)
· Mary Dyer Illuminated (2013)
· Mary Dyer: For Such a Time as This (2014)
· The Dyers of London, Boston, & Newport (2014)
· Effigy Hunter (2015)
· Anne Marbury Hutchinson: American Founding Mother (2018)
http://amzn.to/18zlbtt (Amazon author page)