Wednesday, October 31, 2012

The ghost ship of 1647

© 2012 Christy K Robinson

Replica early-17th-century merchant ship, armed against pirates.
In the early 1640s, seeing their estates shrinking fast in the New World, the merchants of New Haven Colony formed a last-ditch partnership to build and stock a trading ship that could bypass the large ports (and of course fees) of Massachusetts Bay, and trade directly with England.

The tonnage of the ship was variously reported as 80, 100, and 150 tons, and there are claims that it was built at Long Island, New Haven, or Newport. (If it was built at Newport as the Bostonian Cotton Mather wrote, the Puritans could blame the heretical, godless Rhode Islanders for its faults!) The ship may have been built shoddily or too hastily, because it was liable to roll over, according to its master, Mr. George Lamberton, who “often said she would prove their grave.”  

 “The Shippe never went voyage before, & was verye Cranckesided,” wrote Governor John Winthrop of Boston. "Crank-sided" means lop-sided or askew. Oh, dear! Imagine trying to stand upright, or the distribution of cargo weight.

In January 1646, the ship set out from New Haven, loaded with wheat, beaver pelts, hides, and other goods valued at £5,000, which would be worth perhaps US$645,000 today. Because this was the coldest decade of the Little Ice Age, the ship’s master had to break through three miles of harbor ice to get out to Long Island Sound. There were about 70 people aboard the nameless ship. Part of the way, they were accompanied by their ultra-conservative Puritan minister, Mr. Davenport, who had close ties to Governor Winthrop, and who later became one of Boston’s ministers and magistrates. (Rev. Davenport had come to Massachusetts in 1630 in the Winthrop Fleet.) Many friends, investors, and well-wishers followed the ship to the harbor’s mouth, with prayers and tears, and heard Davenport pray,
“Lord, if it be thy pleasure to bury these our friends in the bottom of the sea, they are thine; save them!” 
(Yes, Davenport appears to have forgotten to take his happy pills that day.)
Click to enlarge. Page
from Cotton Mather's

Magnalia Christi Americana,
 about the ship.

Reverend Cotton Mather, in 1703, wrote that 
“Alas, the ship was never after heard of! she foundered in the sea; and in her were lost, not only the hopes of their future trade, but also the lives of several excellent persons, as well as divers manuscripts of some great men in the country, sent over for the service of the church, which were now buried in the ocean. The fuller story of that grievous matter, let the reader with a just astonishment accept from the pen of the reverend person [James Pierpont], who is now the pastor of New-Haven.”
Those lost were the ship's commander George Lamberton, (militia) Capt. Nathaniel Turner, "Thomas Gregson [my direct ancestor], Mrs. Goodyear, and seven or eight figures of importance." Mrs. Goodyear was the first wife of New Haven deputy governor Stephen Goodyear, who later married the widow of George Lamberton! Many of the rest of the 70 people aboard would have been ship's crew.

The godly people of New Haven, not hearing the fate of the passengers or their investments after 18 months had elapsed, fasted and prayed that the Lord would let them hear what he had done with them, and to prepare them to accept his will. A great thunderstorm blew up one day in June, and an hour before sunset, a ship of similar dimensions to the one which left in January appeared in the sky over New Haven harbor’s mouth and sailed into the north wind for half an hour. (Toward, not away from, the thunderstorm, which makes its appearance more significant.)

Rev. James Pierpont wrote his eyewitness account of the spectral ship.
Click to enlarge. Page
from Cotton Mather's

Magnalia Christi Americana,
 about the ship.
“A great thunderstorm arose out of the northwest; after which (the hemisphere being serene) about an hour before sunset a ship of like dimensions with the aforesaid, with her canvass and colours abroad (though the wind northerly) appeared in the air coming up from our harbour's mouth, which lyes southward from the town, seemingly with her sails filled under a fresh gale, holding her course north, and continuing under observation, sailing against the wind for the space of half an hour.

“Many were drawn to behold this great work of God; yea, the very children cryed out, There's a brave ship! At length, crowding up as far as there is usually water sufficient for such a vessel, and so near some of the spectators, as that they imagined a man might hurl a stone on board her, her main-top seemed to be blown off, but left hanging in the shrouds; then her missen-top; then all her masting seemed blown away by the board: quickly after the hulk brought unto a careen, she overset, and so vanished into a smoky cloud, which in some time dissipated, leaving, as everywhere else, a clear air. The admiring spectators could distinguish the several colours of each part, the principal rigging, and such proportions, as caused not only the generality of persons to say, This was the mould of their ship, and thus was her tragick end: but Mr. Davenport also in publick declared to this effect, That God had condescended, for the quieting of their afflicted spirits, this extraordinary account of his sovereign disposal of those for whom so many fervent prayers were made continually.”

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow wrote of the phantom ship,
A ship sailed from New Haven,
And the keen and frosty airs,
That filled her sails at parting,
Were heavy with good men's prayers.

"O Lord! if it be thy pleasure"---
Thus prayed the old divine---
"To bury our friends in the ocean,
Take them, for they are thine!"

But Master Lamberton muttered,
And under his breath said he,
This ship is so crank and walty
I fear our grave she will be!"

And the ships that came from England,
When the winter months were gone,
Brought no tidings of this vessel
Nor of Master Lamberton.

This put the people to praying
That the Lord would let them hear
What in his greater wisdom
He had done with friends so dear.

And at last their prayers were answered:---
It was in the month of June,
An hour before the sunset
Of a windy afternoon,

When, steadily steering landward,
A ship was seen below,
And they knew it was Lamberton, Master,
Who sailed so long ago.

On she came, with a cloud of canvas,
Right against the wind that blew,
Until the eye could distinguish
The faces of the crew.

Then fell her straining topmasts,
Hanging tangled in the shrouds,
And her sails were loosened and lifted,
And blown away like clouds.

And the masts, with all their rigging,
Fell slowly, one by one,
And the hulk dilated and vanished,
As a sea-mist in the sun!

And the people who saw this marvel
Each said unto his friend,
That this was the mould of their vessel,
And thus her tragic end.

And the pastor of the village
Gave thanks to God in prayer,
That, to quiet their troubled spirits,
He had sent this Ship of Air.

What do you think? Was it a cumulus cloud made colorful by the sunset? Was it a ship of lost spirits? Was it a divine sign? Scores of serious and sober eyewitnesses thought it was the latter. Hurricanes, earthquakes, plagues, comets, eclipses, and other natural phenomena were always considered to be messages from God, to be interpreted by their ministers.

Shipbuilding went on very successfully in New England, but the principal building yards were in Massachusetts, Maine, and at Newport, not at New Haven. Typically, a ship would be built, loaded with cargo, and sailed to Europe, where it was sold after only one or two voyages. America’s shipyards built thousands of merchant and military ships during the 17th century. But the phantom ship of New Haven was never seen again.

New Haven’s lost ship, carrying 70 souls and the hopes and fortunes of many more, was part of the unmaking of the colony. In 1662, Charles II issued a charter (granting rights of self-government) to Connecticut Colony, based in Hartford, and the unchartered New Haven merged with their neighbor.

Christy K Robinson is the author of three books on William and Mary Dyer, which include many of their contemporaries: Anne Marbury Hutchinson, Edward Hutchinson, Katherine Scott, Henry Vane, John Winthrop, Jeremiah Clarke, John Cotton, and many others. You may find them at .

Christy K Robinson is author of the books:
·          We Shall Be Changed (2010)
·          Mary Dyer Illuminated (2013)
·          Mary Dyer: For Such a Time as This (2014)
·          The Dyers of London, Boston, & Newport (2014)
·          Effigy Hunter (2015)
·          Anne Marbury Hutchinson: American Founding Mother (2018)


  1. Greetings, Where is that image of New England shipbuilding from? I could use it for a project I'm doing in Salem, MA. Thanks so much! -Bonnie Smith

    1. Thanks for asking, Bonnie. I believe that I found it in an old PDF when I was searching for info on 17th-century New England shipbuilding. The text surrounding the image referred to the building of boats in New Hampshire's rivers, where timber was plentiful. I did a screenshot and cleaned it up in Photoshop. I've been searching for that document for 45 minutes and can't find it now.

  2. Do you have a list of the passengers?

    1. I found a few names in various genealogical websites. The ship was carrying trade cargo, primarily, so I doubt it had very many passengers, but the names I discovered were the ship's commander George Lamberton, (militia) Capt. Nathaniel Turner, "Thomas Gregson, Mrs. Goodyear, and seven or eight figures of importance." Mrs. Goodyear was the first wife of New Haven deputy governor Stephen Goodyear, who married the widow of George Lamberton!

      This is only my guess, but the rest of the 70 people aboard would have been ship's crew.

  3. Hi Christy, Thanks for the reply. My husband is a direct descendant of Capt. Lamberton, and I am descended from Thomas Gregson, whose daughter was married and living in Guilford. I am looking for any passengers who were from Guilford. Tracy

  4. Appreciate this blogs concise telling and links to the Cotton Mather page, Thanks

  5. Thank you for the information on the Phantom Ship. I am a descendant of Nathaniel Turner.
    J Brock

  6. I enjoyed your information about the Phantom Ship. I am a direct descendant of Captain Lamberton. It is such a sad and amazing story

  7. Thank you for this info. I, too, am a descendant of Thomas Gregson and Capt. Nathanial Turner. Also, I am descended from Mrs. Goodyear's husband, Stephen. Do you know why Mrs. Goodyear was traveling back to England? It seems unusual for a woman in those days.

    1. You're welcome, Anonymous. It actually was not unusual for New England women to travel back to England, where they had family members they'd thought they might never see again. They also had business concerns back in the home country they might have left five to ten years before, or perhaps a parent died and there was an estate to settle. The King's government, which oppressed Puritans, was in disarray during the civil wars, and the Puritan majority was in control. Not only did New Englanders visit their old home, but many families moved back permanently.

    2. Upon coming to the new country, some persons decided not to risk the lives of all of their children, leaving some back in England with their grandparents. Also, the possibility of death for very young children would be high. (Part of my family was shipwrecked off the Canadian coast in 1821: the only victim on the while ship was a 3-year-old.) After seeing all safe and sound in America, the retrieval trip could occur.

  8. Thank you so much for this report, Christy! Did you ever happen to find a name for this ship? I have been searching and I'm worried I missed it somewhere obvious, but I just can't find it. Thank you!

  9. Message from my website mail

    Ghost Shippe
    I read your blog on the Ghost Shippe. I am descended from Captain Nathaniel Turner. An interesting footnote: Turner came over with John Winthrop to Boston in 1630. He would have been very familiar with Winthrop's Model of Christian Charity and the curse Winthrop put on them if they should "dissemble" with God." Turner and the New Haven Colony were very fixed on success financially. Remember they lost their colony on the Delaware to the Dutch, a great financial loss. The Ghost Shippe was their final hope for success. But is this not what Winthrop warned about?: "but if we shall neglect the observation of these articles which are the ends we have propounded, and, dissembling with our God, shall fall to embrace this present world and prosecute our carnal intentions, seeking great things for ourselves and our posterity, the Lord will surely break out in wrath against us, and be revenged of such a people, and make us know the price of the breach of such a covenant. Now the only way to avoid this shipwreck, . . . " Was the Ghost Shippe wreck just the fulfillment of Winthrop's curse? Kevin Durkin

    1. Thank you for your interesting comments, Kevin.

      I'm not sure that the wreck was a result of a curse, but if you believe in the power of a curse, that could be one theory.

      I do know that John Winthrop and his government participated in some underhanded activities, including having the sachem Miantonomo killed, and abducting Rhode Island men from their farms near Warwick. They arrested, imprisoned, and attempted to extort massive fines for Anne Hutchinson's son and son-in-law. And the Boston governors may have had a hand in Anne Hutchinson's family massacre in 1643, if you believe some writers who personally knew her and the situation. I covered those events in my new book, "Anne Marbury Hutchinson, American Founding Mother."

  10. "Lamberton's Ship" or the Phantom Ship (at sea Sulawesi Tengah, Indonesia) is the notation on my ancestors death Francis Brewster was his name. The date matches. I thought the Indonesia part was weird

    1. I don't see that a Francis Brewster was a passenger on this ship, and the ship most certainly never made it to Indonesia, which at the time was a Dutch territory (the "Dutch Indies"). The New Haven ship most certainly went down on its maiden voyage in January 1646, in Long Island Sound or the Atlantic Ocean between New England and old England. Because there's no editorial review or process, you can trust about as much as teachers trust Wikipedia!

    2. Francis Brewster was partner in the ownership of the ship. It is presumed he died on it through colonial probate records. See the American Genealogist Vol 12 page 206 published in 1935.

    3. Here's the reference to Francis Brewster mentioned directly above:,+Brewster&source=bl&ots=7pstqDW4Yz&sig=qQfFgPKPFtXr7-q-qJZeAuaWub8&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjc29y9lM7fAhUAHTQIHcpaBz4Q6AEwAHoECAoQAQ#v=onepage&q=American%20Genealogist%20Vol%2012%20page%20206%2C%20Brewster&f=false

      If you copy and paste that long URL, you should open a PDF of the magazine article.

  11. My Taylor Family lore has another puritan; "John Taylor," on that ship also. His wife Rhoda Tinker filed his will which was written Nov. 1645,before the sailing of the ship,"Fellowship." They had at least two sons: John & Thomas. Among the descendents from New Milford, Ct. was Nathaniel W.Taylor. b.1786. See "Nathaniel Taylor, New Haven Theology, by Sweeney, isbn 0-19-51-5428-2, Oxford Press 2003.Pg. 15-19. Also the numerous references given on Pg.158-9.
    About 1800 some descendents moved to Bradford County, PA. settling along Wyalusing creek. Abraham a Revolutionary War teamster is buried in the old Stevensville cemetery. I'm descended from Abe's second son: Nathan, born in New Milford who moved with Abe to Pa. and later to St. Clair, Illinois 1838. Coincidently (probably not because there were Dyers in New Milford also) one of Nathans daughters; Belinda, married Ephraim Dyer. Ref.(Aug. 18,1856, Butte County, Calif. probate for Charles Taylor/another of Nathans's sons). note: Ephraim & Belinda Taylor Dyer had at least 10 children. Ref 1860 census, household 1063, Pike, Bradford County, PA.
    This story stretches from coast to coast. Charles Taylor and Ephraim Fairchild arrived @ Sutters Fort in Ca. with the Charles Hopper wagon train out of Fort Hall (twenty wagons & 100 people)in 1847. (Ref: Sutters Diary, Oct. 4, 1847). Also: (" William Alexander Trubody and the Overland Pioneers of 1847 by Charles L Camp").

    Russell W. Taylor, Calif.

  12. Very interesting post. I do believe, however, that John Davenport came seven years after the Winthrop Fleet, on the Hector, with some of his congregation.

  13. John Taylor is one of my great grandfather's on my dad's side. Very interesting story here.

  14. Commenter Russell W. Taylor of California names the phantom ship “Fellowship.” I have not seen an actual name given in any other on-line articles about the real ship, the loss of it or the legendary apparition. I would ask Russell (or any of you) if you know a primary source for the name of the ship or was the name from family lore of the Taylor’s. The building of the ship was such a major investment for New Haven that it seems implausible that the ship was not given a name.

    Another unresolved aspect seems to be:
    Was the ship built in New Haven or Newport, R.I.? Does anyone have a primary source on this detail.

    Excellent article and discussion. Our family is descended from Francis Brewster (the younger), father of Rev. Nathaniel. Francis was on the ship by many accounts and had some ownership in the vessel.

    —Maribeth Zay Fischer, Indianapolis

  15. Great story, my wife’s 9th great grandfather was on that ship, his name was Dr. Francis Brewster He was a barber surgeon

  16. Great story. I just recently discovered Capt. George Lambertson is my 10th Great Grandfather. Is there any more information about him find?? Thank you.

    1. I don't have further information on Mr Lamberton, but you might attempt a reply to Tracy Tomaselli above to see if she does.


Reasonable, thoughtful comments are encouraged. Impolite comments will be moderated to the recycle bin. NO LINKS or EMAIL addresses: I can't edit them out of your comment, so your comment will not be published. This is for your protection, and to screen out spam and porn.